SEC Commissioner Hester Peirce, often referred to as ‘Crypto Mom’ by enthusiasts in the digital currency space, has voiced her concerns regarding the United States Securities and Exchange Commission’s (SEC) current regulatory stance towards cryptocurrencies.
Speaking at the SEC Speaks Conference on April 2, Peirce highlighted issues with the agency’s guidance on crypto custody, particularly pointing out the limitations imposed by Staff Accounting Bulletin 121 (SAB 121) issued in March 2022. Her critique underscores a broader debate on the SEC’s approach to regulating emerging technologies and its impact on innovation within the crypto sector.
SEC's Hester Peirce criticizes SAB 121, urging open dialogue and innovation-friendly crypto regulation. pic.twitter.com/D1drfIScXN
— TechTiynypen News (@TechTinypen) April 3, 2024
Concerns Over SAB 121 and Its Implications
The focal point of Peirce’s critique was SAB 121, a bulletin that sets forth the SEC’s accounting guidelines for institutions wishing to custody crypto assets. Peirce argued that the bulletin, which effectively restricts many banks from offering crypto custody services to their clients, was introduced without adequate input from the banking sector. She emphasized that such restrictions not only limit the involvement of experienced financial institutions in the crypto custody space but may also inadvertently heighten risks for investors.
Read also: Singapore Central Bank Expands Payment Services Act for Digital Token Oversight
Meanwhile, Peirce highlighted the potential for assets to be treated as part of a failed custodian’s estate rather than being clearly attributable to the customers should the custodian entity collapse.
The Call for Open Dialogue and Clear Guidance
Moreover, Peirce expressed concerns regarding the SEC’s perceived reluctance to engage openly with stakeholders in the crypto space. She noted a shift in the agency’s culture that has led to a more insular approach to policy development and public engagement.
According to Peirce, this shift has fostered an environment of apprehension among investors and companies, who fear that interactions with the SEC could lead to enforcement actions, particularly in areas like crypto, which the agency has earmarked for increased scrutiny. Peirce advocated for a restoration of open communication channels between the SEC and the public, emphasizing the need for clear, actionable guidance that supports, rather than stifles, responsible innovation in the sector.
Industry Support and Legislative Response
Peirce’s remarks have resonated within the crypto community and among industry leaders. Paul Grewal, Chief Legal Officer at Coinbase, publicly supported Peirce’s call for the establishment of an advisory committee to understand better the practical implications of regulatory rules on the crypto industry in a post on X. This suggestion aligns with the broader industry call for regulations that are both clear and conducive to technological innovation and growth.
There's lots to agree with in Commissioner @HesterPeirce's remarks this week at SEC Speaks. But one suggestion struck me as especially creative and unobjectionable to anyone not focused on a political agenda at the SEC: an advisory committee made up of chief compliance…
— paulgrewal.eth (@iampaulgrewal) April 3, 2024
Additionally, legislative actions, such as the resolution passed by the House Financial Services Committee (HSFC) on March 1 to overturn SAB 121, reflect a growing concern within certain sectors of the government regarding the SEC’s current regulatory posture towards digital assets.
